As the government consults on a national policy statement for data centres, a new working paper sets out what is known about the sector’s environmental footprint, what is not, and six ways to close the gap.
The data needed to judge what UK data centres cost the environment does not exist in usable form, according to Data Centres and Environmental Impact, a new paper by Differentis, Sunnyhill Consultants and Mehtadology.
The authors examined 23 key questions that planners, regulators, communities, and buyers of digital services might reasonably ask about a data centre, across water, energy, and carbon, land, chemicals and waste, noise, air quality and light, and governance. The paper found that only four can be answered from published data.
“Eleven are not collected by anyone,” said Dave King, Chief Executive Officer of Differentis, who added that the gap is starkest on water.
Thames Water’s own business plan estimates that a single large facility could use between 4 and 19 million litres a day, yet no UK data centre is required to report its water use. Global Action Plan has found that 84% of new data centres proposed for the UK are in areas already water-stressed or expected to be by 2040.
Europe has taken a different route, with EU data centres of 500 kW or more reporting energy and water performance every year since 2024, and a public A to G rating is proposed from August 2027.
The environmental footprint of data centres
The paper from the three consulting firms comes at a time that UK policy is moves quickly. The Data Centre Covenant, announced by the Chancellor as part of his Autumn Budget late October, offers faster grid connections and planning support to so-called ‘strategic’ data centres that meet five tests, including environmental standards.
However, while only strategic sites must report their energy and water use, what counts as strategic has not yet been defined. A draft National Policy Statement for data centres was published for consultation the same day.
“Planning committees, regulators, and communities are being asked to make decisions that will shape water supplies, land, and carbon budgets for decades, without the basic facts they need. The data could be collected. But nobody has yet been required to collect it,” said Jayne Manley of Sunnyhill Consultants.
“The draft National Policy Statement is the clearest near-term opportunity to change that. The Covenant moves in the right direction, but its binding tests reach only strategic sites. Anyone with a stake in where these buildings go should read the evidence and respond to the consultation before it closes.”
AI’s boost to demand
The rapid growth of artificial intelligence is driving unprecedented demand for data centre computing capacity. According to research by McKinsey & Company, global demand for data centre capacity could more than triple by 2030, with AI workloads accounting for much of this growth.
“AI is changing the arithmetic. The energy needed for a simple query is falling, but reasoning models and AI agents working continuously inside everyday processes need far more,” said Ashwin Mehta of Mehtadology. “As organisations move from occasional use to agents running all day, per-query figures will understate what they really consume. It is imperative to know what it costs.”
‘Greater transparency’
The working paper outlines six recommendations, including mandatory reporting of energy consumption, water use, refrigerants and waste by data centres with a capacity of 500 kW or more, alongside the creation of a public national register.
Another recommendation calls on organisations procuring AI and cloud services to require suppliers to disclose the energy consumption, water use and carbon emissions associated with their services. King: “Every organisation buying cloud and AI services is making environmental decisions, whether it realises it or not. The Covenant is aimed at developers rather than buyers, which is why this recommendation matters. Any buyer can act on it today, ahead of legislation.”
Ultimately, the three authors emphasise that their paper neither advocates for nor opposes data centres. Instead, it calls for greater transparency around the sector’s environmental footprint and more effective management of its impact. To support this, the authors have developed a practical checklist of questions that residents, local councillors and IT buyers can put to data centre developers and technology suppliers.